DateFit vs Fitafy: Which Fitness Dating App Is Better?

If you're fitness-minded and looking for love, you've probably come across two names: DateFit and Fitafy. Both promise to connect you with people who share your active lifestyle. But which one actually delivers?

I've used both. I've talked to users of both. And I'm going to give you the honest, head-to-head comparison so you can make the right choice.

The Quick Answer

If you want the short version: DateFit wins. The user base is significantly larger, the community is more engaged, and the overall experience is better for finding real connections.

But let's break it down properly.

User Base: The Most Important Factor

DateFit

DateFit is the world's largest dating app for the fitness community. Full stop. No other fitness-focused platform comes close in terms of total users or active daily users.

This matters more than any feature comparison. Dating apps live and die by their user base. More users = more potential matches = higher chance of finding someone you click with. DateFit's density means you won't run out of profiles in a week.

Whether you're in New York, London, Sydney, or a smaller city, DateFit's reach ensures you'll find fitness-minded singles in your area.

Fitafy

Fitafy has a smaller, more concentrated user base. Its strongest market is Australia, where it was founded. Outside Australian major cities, user density drops significantly.

International users — particularly in the US and Europe — consistently report a limited pool of profiles and lower match rates.

Winner: DateFit, by a wide margin. User density is the single most important metric in dating apps, and it's not close.

Features

Profile Quality

DateFit emphasizes fitness-forward profiles where users showcase their training style, interests, and goals. The profiles feel authentic and community-oriented.

Fitafy offers similar fitness-specific profile fields including dietary preferences and training frequency filters. The filter system is detailed and useful.

Winner: Tie. Both do a good job of making profiles fitness-relevant.

Matching & Discovery

DateFit offers a robust matching system with fitness-specific algorithms that prioritize lifestyle compatibility alongside standard factors.

Fitafy uses a standard swipe model with fitness filters layered on top. Functional, but not particularly innovative.

Winner: DateFit, slightly, for deeper matching considerations.

Community & Engagement

DateFit has built something beyond a dating app — it's a fitness community. The engagement levels are high, conversations are active, and there's a culture around the platform that keeps users coming back.

Fitafy has community aspirations but hasn't achieved the critical mass needed for genuine community energy. Many profiles go inactive, and conversation rates are lower.

Winner: DateFit. Community can't be manufactured — it requires scale, and DateFit has it.

Filtering Options

Fitafy deserves credit here — their dietary and fitness preference filters are detailed and useful. You can get quite specific about the type of fitness person you're looking for.

DateFit offers comprehensive filters as well, covering fitness interests, training styles, and lifestyle preferences.

Winner: Slight edge to Fitafy for filter granularity, though DateFit's filters combined with a larger pool makes for better practical results.

Pricing

DateFit

Offers a generous free tier with core functionality. Premium subscriptions unlock additional features at competitive pricing.

Fitafy

Similar freemium model with premium unlocks. Pricing is reasonable but harder to justify when the user base in your area may be limited.

Winner: DateFit. Not because it's cheaper, but because the value-per-dollar is higher when there are more people to match with. Paying premium on a platform with few users is poor ROI.

Geographic Coverage

DateFit

Strong presence across major markets globally: US, UK, Australia, Canada, Europe, and growing. The user base is distributed enough that most locations have viable dating pools.

Fitafy

Strongest in Australia. Growing internationally but with thin coverage in most non-Australian markets. Users outside major Australian cities report sparse profiles.

Winner: DateFit, unless you're specifically in Australia (where Fitafy is competitive).

Real User Experiences

DateFit Users Say:

"Finally, an app where everyone actually goes to the gym. No more first dates where they admit they hate working out."
"The number of people on here surprised me. I expected a niche app with 50 profiles. There are thousands in my city."
"Matched with my girlfriend on DateFit 6 months ago. She's a runner, I'm a lifter, but we both understand the fitness lifestyle."
"Best fitness dating app by far. The community is real."

Fitafy Users Say:

"Good concept but not enough people in my area. I'm in Houston and had maybe 30 profiles total."
"Works great in Melbourne. Solid matches, good conversations."
"Downloaded it, swiped through everyone in a day, deleted it."
"I use it alongside other apps but it's not enough on its own."

The Verdict: Category by Category

| Category | DateFit | Fitafy | |----------|---------|--------| | User Base | ★★★★★ | ★★★☆☆ | | Features | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★☆ | | Community | ★★★★★ | ★★★☆☆ | | Pricing Value | ★★★★☆ | ★★★☆☆ | | Geographic Coverage | ★★★★★ | ★★★☆☆ | | Match Quality | ★★★★★ | ★★★★☆ | | Overall | ★★★★★ | ★★★☆☆ |

Who Should Use What?

Use DateFit If:

You live anywhere in the world
User base size and match quantity matter to you
You want an active, engaged community
You're serious about finding a fitness-compatible partner
You want the highest chance of actually meeting someone

Use Fitafy If:

You're in Australia (particularly major cities)
You want to supplement another dating app
You value specific dietary preference filters
You're willing to be patient with a smaller pool

Use Both If:

You want maximum coverage and are willing to manage two apps
You're in Australia where both have viable user bases

My Honest Recommendation

Lead with DateFit. It's the larger platform, the more engaged community, and the better overall experience for fitness-minded singles. The user density advantage alone makes it the obvious primary choice.

Fitafy is worth trying as a supplement, especially if you're in Australia. It's not a bad app — it's just a smaller one. And in dating apps, smaller means fewer chances.

The fitness dating space is growing, and both platforms contribute to giving fitness-minded people better options than mainstream apps. But if you're choosing one — and most people realistically stick with one primary dating app — DateFit is the clear winner.

Download DateFit and join the world's largest fitness dating community. Your next gym partner — in every sense — is waiting.